Ten years of monopoly
for whoever invents
On 19 March 1474 the Venetian Senate passed a law guaranteeing the author of a new device ten years of exclusivity. Regarded as Europe's first codified patent system, the text treats an invention as a right, not as a favour.
A general law in place of favours
Before 1474, protecting an invention was a matter of privilege: a city granted one man a monopoly, at its pleasure. In 1421 Florence had given Filippo Brunelleschi three years of exclusivity on a cargo boat, in exchange for disclosing his method. The boat sank on its first voyage on the Arno.
The Venetian text changes scale by laying down a general rule. Any "new and ingenious device" not yet made in the Republic's domains is protected once it is perfected and ready for use, provided its author declares it to the Provveditori di Comun, the city's magistrates. For ten years no one may make a similar device without his consent. An infringer pays a fine of one hundred ducats and sees the object destroyed; the inventor may sue before any office in Venice. The Republic reserves the right to use the invention when needed, but only its authors may operate it. Registration is free.
The exchange is explicit: the city offers a temporary monopoly, and the inventor brings it knowledge that he must declare and put to work on its territory. The scheme was used: nearly 1,900 Venetian patents were granted between 1474 and 1788, 28 of them before 1500, 593 in the sixteenth century, 605 in the seventeenth and 670 between 1700 and 1788.
A monopoly lent in exchange for knowledge
The patent rests on a trade-off that has not changed: a monopoly limited in time, granted in return for disclosure. Without protection, the inventor keeps his secret or gets copied; without limits, the rent stifles competition. Ten years, a fine, a mandatory declaration: Venice already sets the three dials that legislators are still adjusting.
Historians disagree about the reach of the law. On the dominant reading it founded the modern system; for Joanna Kostylo it mostly codified existing customs, while protecting individual inventors rather than guilds. A question remains open: how far does protecting an idea stimulate invention, and at what point does it hold back those who come after?
A patent is a monopoly on loan, which the inventor repays by disclosing what he knows.