The toll where the king
could buy the cargo
On 14 March 1857, a convention concluded in Copenhagen put an end to the Sound Dues, which Denmark had levied for more than four centuries on ships passing through the strait. Economists still remember the toll for one ingenious clause: the captain declared the value of his own cargo, but the Crown could buy it from him at that price.
Four centuries of stopping at Helsingør
Introduced in 1429 by King Eric of Pomerania, the Sound Dues fell on foreign ships using the Øresund, the narrow channel linking the Baltic to the North Sea. Every vessel had to stop at Helsingør and pay, under the guns posted on both shores. The strait was the great highway for Baltic grain, timber, hemp and tar; in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries the toll is said to have supplied up to two thirds of the Danish state's revenue.
In 1567 the flat charge per ship gave way to a tax of 1 to 2% of the cargo's value, which tripled the yield. The registers kept at Helsingør, preserved from 1497 to 1857, record close to two million passages: today they are among the richest sources for the history of European trade.
The question was how to know what the goods were worth. Denmark left the estimate to the captain himself, with one safeguard: the Crown reserved the right to buy the cargo at the declared price. Undervaluing to pay less risked giving up the goods at a loss; overvaluing meant paying too much. The most profitable declaration was therefore the most accurate one.
By the nineteenth century the toll had become intolerable to trading nations, and the United States openly disputed its very principle. The Copenhagen Convention bought it out: Europe's maritime powers paid Denmark 33.5 million rigsdaler, roughly a third borne by Britain and another third by Russia. Washington concluded a separate agreement the same year, for some $393,000. The Danish straits became free to merchant shipping.
Letting self-interest tell the truth
The Sound clause anticipates an idea economic theory formalised much later: self-assessment under threat of purchase. When an authority cannot verify the value of an asset itself, it can let the owner announce it, provided the announcement is binding. This is the principle of the so-called Harberger tax, named after the economist Arnold Harberger, who sketched it in the early 1960s, and brought back to the centre of debate by Eric Posner and Glen Weyl in Radical Markets (2018).
The mechanism has its limits. It requires a public buyer able to pay, store and resell, and willing to use its right often enough to stay credible. As for the end of the toll, it is a reminder that a transit rent, however well designed, is eventually bought out once the trade it taxes outweighs the power that collects it.
A tax can obtain the truth without an inspector, provided lying costs more than declaring fairly.