The bank that swore
never to lend
On 31 January 1609, the city of Amsterdam founded the Wisselbank, an exchange bank meant to bring order to a chaos of coins. It was not supposed to lend anything: that promise made its money valuable, and breaking it brought the bank down.
A currency that existed only in a ledger
In the early seventeenth century, some five hundred different coins, legal or not, from all over Europe, circulated in the Dutch Republic. Clipped, worn and of uneven fineness, they made every payment uncertain. The city answered with a new kind of institution: merchants deposited their coin at the Wisselbank, which weighed it, assayed it and credited it to their account. Payments were then made by simple transfer from one account to another, without a single coin changing hands.
To enforce the system, the city required every bill of exchange of 600 guilders or more to be settled through the bank. The bank guilder, tied to a fixed weight of silver, became the unit of account of long-distance trade. It traded against current coin at a premium, the agio, usually between 4 and 5%. From 1683, a system of receipts also allowed depositors to withdraw their metal within six months for a small fee.
The founding rule was full reserves: every guilder on the books was to be matched by metal kept in the bank's vaults. Adam Smith, in The Wealth of Nations (1776), devoted a long digression to it and set out its workings guilder by guilder, as a model of a deposit bank.
Trust rests on the rule, not on the metal
For nearly two centuries the Wisselbank pulled off a remarkable feat: its book money was worth more than the coins it stood for. The premium did not pay for the metal but for safety, the convenience of transfers and the certainty of a constant weight. Some historians see it as the first true central bank, even though it did not manage the country's currency or lend to the public.
Yet the rule was broken in secret. The Dutch East India Company obtained large unsecured advances that it could not repay after the Fourth Anglo-Dutch War. In 1790 the agio vanished; by the end of the year the bank declared itself insolvent. In 1795 the Batavian Revolution broke the secrecy of its books, and the Wisselbank entered liquidation in 1819. The lesson reaches beyond Amsterdam: money with no tangible form can be worth more than silver itself, for as long as whoever keeps the ledger honours the announced rule. Every dematerialised currency still raises the same question: who checks that the rule is kept?
Ledger money is worth exactly what the word of the ledger-keeper is worth.